OpenSciEd 8.1, Lesson 7: Changes in Kinetic Energy Investigation (Vernier Powered, Guided)
Task
Use this Vernier-Powered Tuva Investigation with the Grade 8 OpenSciEd curriculum during Unit 8.1, Lesson 7. Tuva has digitized Procedure for Investigation 1 and the data tables from Changes in Kinetic Energy: Investigations #1 & 2 and Graphing Kinetic Energy Relationships used in lesson Parts 3–9. Students measure their cart's speed with a Vernier Go Direct Sensor Cart, record their data, and use the Tuva Tools to create data visualizations that help them make sense of it and respond to questions. Each group will need a Go Direct Sensor Cart and a computer running Chrome or Edge, the two browsers that can connect to the cart. The Sensor Cart measures its own speed as it rolls, so it takes the place of the cart and timer listed on each group's materials list in the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition. Tuva is used to deepen data sensemaking; it is not a standalone lesson. Use it in tandem with the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition to guide overall instruction and collaborative sensemaking. Where This Investigation Fits into the Storyline In Lesson 6, students determined that we needed to figure out what causes more damage and energy transfer in a collision--increases in mass or increases in speed. This lesson is a multi-step investigation where students explore how doubling the mass or doubling the speed of a moving object affects its kinetic energy and the damage it can do in a collision. When to Use Tuva Day One Complete OpenSciEd Part 1, Navigation, and Part 2, Planning Our Investigation, outside of Tuva. Then, before having students begin carrying out the cracker damage investigation, have them open Tuva. They will read the procedure for the experiment on Tuva, record data in a table on Tuva, and use the Tuva Tools to explore their data. Note: Readings collected with the cart are held in the browser and are lost if the page is reloaded, so plan for each group to work through Steps 4 to 8 — connecting the cart, the runs for Conditions A, B, and C, and entering their data — in one sitting. Students write each condition's speed on paper as they go, so they still have it for Step 8. Pause to complete Part 4, the gallery walk of cracker damage and a class discussion about the evidence. (Use pages 14–16 of the Teacher Edition for guidance.) The beginning of Part 5 will also happen off of Tuva. You will problematize the need to quantify the energy transferred to the cracker and introduce a strategy for doing so. The end of Part 5, where students are recording data from the videos, should be done on Tuva. Then, end your day with the Turn and Talk. (Pages 15–18 will help you facilitate this section.) Day Two Resume Day 2 outside of Tuva with the Navigation Routine and Planning for Using a Computational Simulation (pages 20-22 of the Teacher Edition). Have students log onto Tuva for Part 8, Collecting and Graphing Data From a Computational Simulation. Students will record the data in Tuva and use the Tuva Tools to create their graph. During Part 9, students analyze and interpret their results. The questions introduced in Part 9 on the slides are included in Tuva. Provide support as needed. Suggestions for supporting students and creating an anchor chart are included on pages 25-28 of the Teacher Edition. Specifically, highlight the term scale factor (ratio of new to old value) when students divide condition distances to reinforce CCSS Math 7.RP.A.2 and CCC Scale, Proportion, and Quantity. What Happens Next? Directly after closing Tuva, teachers will guide students through Part 10 and 11. Probe Setup Charge the Go Direct Sensor Carts the night before you use them. Each group needs 2 Go Direct Sensor Carts: one connects to Tuva, and the second is taped on top of it to double the mass in Condition B. Group size: Make groups of 3–5 students. Setup Set up a track at each station as you did in previous lessons. Secure the track using tape in such a way that you can slip a piece of paper under one end of the track. Remove the anti-roll peg from under the carts if you are not using a Vernier Dynamics Track (the third track option below) for this investigation. Use one of these three track options: 1. Tape down a strip of wood, metal, or plastic that is 1 meter long, 4 cm wide, and 0.5 cm thick (3 feet long, 1.75 inches wide, and 3/16 inches thick) so the cart can run over it. ![Two Go Direct Sensor Carts, one green and one blue, sitting on a long, narrow metal strip taped to a wooden table.]500 2. Tape down two meter sticks so they are at least 10 cm (4 inches) apart so the cart can run between them. ![Two Go Direct Sensor Carts sitting between two meter sticks taped to a table.]500 3. Use a dynamics track adjusted so it is level. ![Two Go Direct Sensor Carts sitting on a level aluminum dynamics track.]500 Stick the fuzzy side of hook and loop fasteners to each 10-N push-pull spring scale (one scale per group). Attach two corresponding pieces of the rough side of hook and loop fasteners to one end of each track, the same distance apart as the fasteners on the spring scale. ![A 10-N push-pull spring scale above the end of a metal track. Two black hook and loop fastener pieces are stuck to the track.]400 Mount the 10-N push-pull spring scale on the track. ![A 10-N push-pull spring scale mounted on the end of a metal track and held in place with blue painter's tape.]400 Test the investigation (Steps 4–7 in Tuva, Procedure for Investigation 1) to make sure the cracker does get damaged, at least in Condition C. The investigation as written assumes a generic soda cracker, which cracks relatively easily. Other crackers, such as some brand-name crackers labeled "crispy & thin", may crack even more easily; you may want to try those instead. Fresh crackers damage more easily than stale ones, and high-humidity environments can keep the crackers from being damaged. If this happens, there are two options: Boost the strength of the spring-scale launcher by a factor of two by mounting two 10-N spring scales side by side on the track. Swap in a stronger spring scale. If you do this, change the launch forces students use in Conditions A, B, and C by the same scale factor. For example, if you swap a 20-N scale in for a 10-N one, double the launch forces in Steps 5–7 from 5 N, 7 N, and 10 N to 10 N, 14 N, and 20 N, and tell students the new values. ![Two green 10-N push-pull spring scales mounted side by side on the end of a track with blue painter's tape.]300 Check that your crackers are no taller than the height of one cart. If they are, students will need to offset the top cart when the carts are stacked so that the top cart does not touch the cracker during the collision. This keeps the area of the cart that hits the cracker the same in Condition B and Condition C.
You have been figuring out that moving objects have kinetic energy, and that more kinetic energy means bigger forces in a collision, and bigger forces can cause more damage. In this investigation, we will be answering: How much does doubling the speed or doubling the mass affect the kinetic energy of an object and the resulting damage that it can do in a collision? Some of you predicted doubling the mass would affect kinetic energy more. Some predicted speed would. Maybe some of you thought they would cause equal amounts of damage. Today you are going to collect evidence to find out. Click Next to get started.
Topics and standards: Physical Science, MS-PS3-1, MS-ETS1-2, MS-LS1-8, Grade 8, MS-PS2-2, MS-ETS1-1, OpenSciEd, 3.1.6-8.H, 3.2.6-8.H, 3.2.6-8.L, 6-MS-PS2-2, 6-MS-PS3-1