OpenSciEd 6.2, Lesson 9: Heat or Cold Through the Cup Wall Investigation (Vernier Powered, Guided)
Task
Use this Vernier-Powered Tuva Investigation with OpenSciEd Unit 6.2, Lesson 9. Tuva has digitized the Investigation: Heat or Cold through the Cup Wall handout used in Part 3. Students work in pairs and collect the water bath temperatures with Vernier Go Direct Temperature Probes. Each pair will need 2 Go Direct Temperature Probes, 1 double temperature probe holder, and 2 computers running Chrome or Edge, the two browsers that can connect to a probe. A probe sends its data to only one computer, so each partner connects to their own probe. Each pair is assigned one of the four cup-and-container combinations and collects one fifteen-minute run. One partner's computer is connected to the probe in the water inside the cup, and the other partner's computer to the probe in the water in the container, so both temperatures are collected at the same time. Allow about 20 minutes for the setup and the run. Note: Readings collected with a probe are held in the browser and are lost if the page is reloaded, so plan for each pair to collect and graph in one sitting. The graph students submit in Step 8 is saved with their work. Decide how students will share data. In Step 10, students follow your instructions for getting data from groups that tested the other combinations: for example, pairs post their temperatures on the board, or share them within a set group of 8 (four pairs, one per combination). This is not a standalone lesson. Use it in tandem with the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition to guide overall instruction and collaborative sensemaking. Where This Investigation Fits into the Storyline Students just discovered that, even without light, water warms up. This led to the conclusion that something else must be moving heat or cold. This lesson has them test whether heat or cold can move through a cup wall. When to Use Tuva Complete Parts 1–2, Navigation and Initial Ideas Discussion, outside of Tuva. (Use pages 6–8 of the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition for guidance.) Before beginning Part 3, have students open this Tuva Investigation. Whether you have opted to run this lab as a whole group demo or in small groups, students will record their investigation plan in Steps 1 to 3. (If running this in a large group, pages 9-11 will be helpful.) Steps 4 to 7 walk pairs through the materials, the water bath setup, connecting the probes, and the collection run. Assign each pair one of the four combinations before they reach Step 5. During the Analyze the Data portion of Part 3, students graph their data and compare their graphs with their partner in Step 8, pool the class temperatures in Step 10, and answer the analysis questions in Step 11. The very last portion of Part 3 is a whole-group discussion. Students may utilize their graphs and responses in Tuva during the discussion. (Use pages 13–14 of the Teacher Edition to facilitate.) What Happens Next Part 4, Navigation, happens completely outside of Tuva. Additional Teacher Notes The OpenSciEd Teacher Edition offers three options for carrying out this lesson: whole-group lab, small-group lab, or data analysis only. This supplement offers the same three options. Step 12 of this Tuva Investigation holds the pre-collected data set, so, if you choose the data analysis only option, have students skip ahead to Step 12.
In the last lesson, we figured out that light warms up the water inside a cup when the cup surface lets light pass through or absorbs it. But we also noticed that the water warmed up even in cups in the dark condition, where there was no light at all. So something else must be moving through the cup wall. We think it might be heat or cold. In this investigation, you will be answering: How does the temperature of a liquid on one side of a cup wall affect the temperature of a liquid on the other side of the wall? Click Next to get started
Topics and standards: Physical Science, MS-PS3-4, MS-PS3-5, MS-PS3-3, MS-PS1-4, MS-PS4-2, Grade 6, OpenSciEd, 3.2.6-8.B, 3.2.6-8.M, 3.2.6-8.N, 3.2.6-8.O, 3.2.6-8.R, 6-MS-PS4-2, 7-MS-PS1-4, 7-MS-PS3-4, 8-MS-PS3-3, 8-MS-PS3-5