OpenSciEd 6.2, Lesson 2: Testing Cup Features Investigation
Task
Use this Tuva Investigation with OpenSciEdUnit 6.2, Lesson 2. Tuva has digitized the student investigation procedure, data table, and class data analysis resources provided in Parts 3, 4, and 5. Tuva is used to deepen data sensemaking; it is not a standalone lesson. Use it in tandem with the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition to guide overall instruction and collaborative sensemaking. Where This Investigation Fits into the Storyline In the first part of this lesson, students review their predictions from Lesson 1 about which cup features matter most and set up a fair test as a class. Now, students will plan and carry out their own cup investigation, collect temperature data, and analyze class data to identify which cup features (lid, walls, material) help keep a drink cold. In the Tuva version of this lesson, data visualizations and statistical labels are intentionally used to scaffold student understanding of certainty and uncertainty in their data. Exploring variability and uncertainty in data underpins the importance of isolating variables in order to establish causation. This sets them up nicely for lesson 4, in which they design a controlled experiment in which they isolate a single variable: the presence or absence of a lid. Read more about this below. When to Use This Data Task Day One Use this Tuva Investigation on Day 1 after completing OpenSciEd lesson Parts 1 and 2 (Navigation and Set Up a Fair Test). Before Part 3 (Plan Cup Investigations in Small Groups), have students pull this Tuva Investigation up on their computers. After Step 2 in Tuva (group plan complete), pause to circulate and check each group's investigation plan before testing begins. Use page 9 of the teacher edition. Finally, students complete steps 4-5 in Tuva. Before they leave for the day, have them submit their data to you. Prep for Day Two At the end of Part 4, the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition, instructs teachers to compile student data in a shared data table or spreadsheet. When you get to this portion of the lesson, after Step 5 in Tuva, you have a few options: Option 1: Use the method suggested in the original OpenSciEd Teacher Edition to pool class data and organize it using spreadsheet software. Option 2: Upload the classwide data into Tuva and share the dataset with your class. Here are two ways to get data into Tuva: Input data into a shared spreadsheet in Excel or Google, and import it into Tuva. Directly insert the data into a Tuva table. Be sure to set up the data table with the following columns instead of the ones provided in the OpenSciEd Materials: Cup, Cup Material, Lid, Straw, Number of Walls, 15-Min Change, 30-Min Change. This will make the data compatible with Tuva. Need help? Visit the Uploading Data into Tuva Help Pages. Day Two If you chose Option 1: Start the day outside of Tuva using pages 13–14 of the OpenSciEd Teacher Edition to help students consider how to organize the data and to work in small groups to analyze it using a spreadsheet. Then, have students get back onto Tuva and complete steps 6-9. These steps provide additional, graph-based ways to consider uncertainty in data. After Step 8, have students turn and talk to discuss certainty and uncertainty in the Cup Material data. Circulate and guides students in noticing that the group means differ, but that not all metal cups outperformed all plastic cups, which makes us a little uncertain about the material's role in keeping liquids cool. (Uncertainty motivates the need for more controlled experimentation in subsequent lessons.) Facilitate the discussion outlined on page 15 of the Teacher Edition. Students will then use both their experience with the spreadsheets and with the Tuva sample data to engage in the discussion. OpenSciEd lesson Parts 6–8 will happen outside of Tuva. If you chose Option 2: Have students navigate to their class on the Tuva Dashboard. Have them go to the Datasets tab on the left. That is where they will find the assigned dataset. As is laid out on page 13 of the Teacher Edition, have students think about and discuss various ways to organize the data. Instead of having them organize their data using a spreadsheet, have them organize their data using the Tuva Tools. You may want to demonstrate first. [--- Demo Instructions Drag any of the independent variables (Cup, Cup Material, Lid, Straw, or Number of Walls) onto the x-axis. Drag any of the dependent variables (15-min. Change or 30-min. Change) onto the y-axis. Choose :ti[dot] or :ti[bar-chart-of-values] from the toolbar. ---] {alert-instruction} Help students think about certainty and uncertainty in their data. (Uncertainty motivates the need for more controlled experimentation in subsequent lessons.) Ask students how certain they are that one group outperformed the other. Give them a chance to explain their thinking. Explain that scientists use math to help them figure out how certain they are. Introduce the term mean. [--- The mean, or average, is a single number that describes a whole group. It helps us compare each group as a whole to other groups. ---] {alert-vocabulary} Show students how to display the mean. Select :ti[mean] and then :ti[labels-on-statistics]. Explain that the bigger the difference between means, the more certain we are two groups are different. Explain that we also want to look at the overlap in the data. If ALL values from one group are greater than ALL values from another group, we can be more certain the groups are different. If there is overlap, we are not sure. In small groups, give students time to organize their data using the other attributes. Have them discuss how certain/ uncertain they are about the role each variable plays in keeping the liquids from changing temperature. Facilitate the discussion outlined on page 15 of the Teacher Edition. Students can use the graphs they have created as evidence during the discussion. OpenSciEd lesson Parts 6–8 will happen outside of Tuva. Note on Mathematical Sequence: In Tuva Lessons 2 and 3 of Unit 6.2, students interact visually with group means and variability (data overlap) to evaluate the effect of structure on function in physical systems. Tuva uses automated tools to display group means and data variability to help students distinguish signal from noise; formal calculation of the mathematical mean is explicitly taught in OpenSciEd Lesson 4. Pedagogical Guidance: Supporting Early Statistical Thinking Data literacy education research shows that introducing the mean visually as a signal within variable data builds strong conceptual statistical reasoning about distributions before students master the formal arithmetic calculations. Mean as Signal: Rather than presenting the mean as an abstract formula or a simple "average," frame it as the overall signal or trend representing how a specific cup design performs as a system. Variability as Noise: Point out the individual data bars around the mean as variation or noise. Encourage students to ask: "Is the difference between the group signals (means) big enough to overcome the noise (overlap in individual cups)? Scientific Certainty: Guide students to realize that when group means are far apart and individual data points do not overlap, we have strong evidence of a real effect (e.g., lidded vs. lidless cups). When means are close or overlap is high (e.g., plastic vs. metal), the data is inconclusive, motivating the need for controlled experiments in Lesson 4.
In the previous lesson, we compared a regular cup and a fancy cup and found the fancy cup kept the drink colder longer. However, we still do not know which features caused that. In this investigation, we will be answering: 1. Which cup features help keep a drink cold? 2. How does changing a cup feature affect how fast the drink warms up? Click Next to get started.
Topics and standards: Physical Science, MS-PS3-4, MS-PS3-5, MS-PS3-3, MS-PS1-4, MS-PS4-2, Grade 6, OpenSciEd, 3.2.6-8.B, 3.2.6-8.M, 3.2.6-8.N, 3.2.6-8.O, 3.2.6-8.R, 6-MS-PS4-2, 7-MS-PS1-4, 7-MS-PS3-4, 8-MS-PS3-3, 8-MS-PS3-5